From Solo Hero to Shared Leadership

The pastor does not have to be the hero of the story. Revs. Rachel Billups and Matt Rawle, co-authors of Dream, Dare, Disrupt, join Joe and Natalie to talk about courageous leadership that is collaborative and adaptive. Rachel shares how her church preaches as a team and measures success by the number of new leaders it names, empowers, trains, and deploys. Matt makes the case for prototyping ministry instead of building programs, and for leading with mission rather than methodology. Along the way: the Jethro principle, lead versus lag indicators, why technology is just a tool for discipleship, and the difference between an audition and a rehearsal.

Rachel serves New Albany United Methodist Church in Ohio. Matt serves St. Matthew's UMC in Metairie and Carrollton UMC in New Orleans. Both work with the Hub for Innovation.

Helpful links

Help us spread the word

  • Tell others: members of your church, coworkers, and anyone else might benefit from these conversations.
  • Share us on Facebook, Instagram and other social media sites.
  • Review us wherever you download the episode. Great reviews help others find us.

Email us about this episode, ideas for future topics, or any other thoughts you would like to share.

More Get Your Spirit in Shape episodes

Thank you for listening, subscribing and sharing. 

This episode posted on November 20, 2026.


Get Your Spirit in Shape and UMC.org are ministries of United Methodist Communications. For more than 80 years, we have been delivering messages of hope and leading the way in communications ministry. Join us in this vital work by making a tax-deductible donation at ResourceUMC.org/GiveUMCom.

Transcript

Introduction

Joe Iovino: Welcome to Get Your Spirit in Shape. I'm Joe Iovino.

Natalie: And I'm Natalie Justice-Taylor.

Joe: I think there are a lot of people in the church who, if you ask them who does the ministry in their church, will say their pastor. That's their first instinct. If that's how you, the listener, would answer that question, boy, do we have a conversation for you today.

Natalie: Today we're very happy to have Reverend Rachel Billups and Reverend Matt Rawle with us. They are the authors of Dream, Dare, Disrupt, and they talk about courageous leadership that is shared, where everyone can be used everywhere. It was a fun conversation, and I hope you'll join in.

Joe: Yes, there was a lot of laughing and a lot of enthusiasm that was absolutely contagious with these two. It's a fantastic conversation, so let's jump in.

Part 1: Introductions and defining courageous leadership

Natalie: Welcome, and thank you so much for joining us. We are so excited to have Reverend Rachel Billups and Reverend Matt Rawle here. They wrote a fantastic book that I've read twice, Dream, Dare, Disrupt. Today we're going to talk about courageous leadership, but first we'd like to hear where you're currently serving. Rachel, Matt, whoever wants to go first. Rock, paper, scissors?

Rachel Billups: I'm going first.

Matt Rawle: Go ahead, Rachel.

Rachel: I'm currently serving as the senior pastor of New Albany United Methodist Church in New Albany, Ohio. New Albany is a fascinating place. It used to be a rural town in the eighties, on the edge of Columbus, and now it's a town of 11,000 in the zip code, with 30,000 people in the school system. It's 60% non-white and 40% white, with 60 countries represented and 40 languages spoken. The world is my parish. It's a really unique setting, especially for the Midwest, and every day is an adventure.

In my spare time I do a little writing, and then coaching and speaking. I'm getting ready to go to Virginia to hang out with their clergywomen. I think there will be about 150 of us, celebrating the 70th anniversary of women's ordination in the United Methodist Church.

I also have a full family. AJ is my oldest. He just turned 21, and I can't believe it. Topher is 18. I have a couple of younger ones who keep me moving. I'm married to my high school sweetheart, John. I grew my first tomatoes on my own this summer, and I'm in my sourdough phase.

Matt: I am not in my sourdough phase. I'm in the stage where, for guys in their mid-forties, you're either really big on World War II history or you smoke meat in the afternoons. Hi everyone, I'm Pastor Matt Rawle.

Rachel: You don't do either of those things, by the way.

Matt: That's correct. I have a nineteen-inch Weber grill. I don't smoke meat, and I know World War II happened, but that's the extent of it. In New Orleans we have the World War II Museum, so I'm in the town where it's all held.

I serve two churches in a dual appointment: St. Matthew's United Methodist in Metairie and Carrollton United Methodist in the city of New Orleans, right at Carrollton and St. Charles. I'm from New Orleans, I'm back home, and I'm a homer. I love the city. It's the air that I breathe. It's a magical place to be in ministry. It's a city that loves being alive, which makes it a dynamic place to be with people. Getting to talk about Jesus is icing on the cake, but the people are just so interesting in everyday walks of life.

I'm also a dad of four. Christy and I have been married almost 25 years, not quite. One of our kids is in college, majoring in art, because I reap what I have sown. My dad's a chemist, and he dropped me off at LSU and said, "Son, what do you want to major in?" I said, "Dad, I think I want to sing." He leaned in real close and said, "Are you sure you want to sing?" Then I dropped off Isabel at Louisiana Lafayette and asked, "What do you want to major in, Izzy?" She said, "I think I want to draw." So I leaned in: "Are you sure you want to draw? Why not do something practical, like music?" I reap what I've sown with my own kids.

I'm living in New Orleans and absolutely loving it, writing on the side. I'm not going to Virginia and doing those cool things, but the parish certainly keeps me busy.

What is courageous leadership?

Natalie: Awesome. Like I said in the introduction, today we're going to talk about courageous leadership. How do you define courageous leadership?

Rachel: We define it in two ways: collaborative and adaptive. We grew up in an era of what [name to verify; transcript reads "George A. Savedo"] sometimes calls solo hero leadership, where it's all about one person. You learn that the buck stops with you, that it all comes through you, that you've got to be the leader. The reality is that's not the picture we see in Scripture, in the Old Testament or the New. It's just not there. And we live in a world where we have to adapt regularly and rapidly. Matt, I'll let you speak more to it.

Matt: We have to move beyond that, especially in a post-pandemic church. Ministry is so different after 2020, so leadership has to be collaborative and adaptive. Rachel is very big on collaborative leadership, and very selfless when it comes to preaching and to voice in the church. What I bring to the table is the adaptability: being able to pivot very quickly and be creative to address things quickly.

Pastors are rarely measured on their level of adaptability, and I think that needs to be a growing metric in how we address positive leadership attributes. Can you pivot? Can you hold the tradition while also moving into something new, for the sake of the people? One of the things I love about the United Methodist Church is that if our theology is not working with real people on the street and in their lives, we go back into the laboratory every four years and figure it out again. That's adaptability.

The future of leadership is collaborative and adaptive, and we have to move away from the idea that the pastor, the Superman or Superwoman, is going to solve all of our problems. That makes Jesus a crutch: if things get bad enough, Jesus will swoop in and fix it, and the pastor will swoop in and make the policy that changes everything. That's not the church. I'm so thankful we had the grace and the space to dive into that and write about it from our own perspectives.

Moving from solo hero to adaptive leadership

Natalie: I like the term adaptive leadership, because you're right, we are so in the hero mindset, and that's not where we need to be. That's what I loved about your book. How have you found moving from the solo mindset to the adaptive one? Where has it been challenging, and where has it been rewarding in your own ministries?

Rachel: The first thing I have to say is that when you're trying to make that shift, it begins with you, because we really do like the accolades. We want the "atta girl" and the "atta boy."

Matt: What do you mean? It's about the medal?

Rachel: Uh-huh. I'm a competitive human being, but I had what I call my crucible of leadership at Ginghamsburg Church. It didn't take me long to recognize that if I try to put it all on my shoulders, then even if I get the gold star, and no one around me is serving out of their call and giftedness, what do I have? A church driven by a single charismatic leader. That's not the church of Jesus. So I began to ask, how do I start sharing the power and privilege I have as a clergyperson with every single lay person on the face of the planet? And I have to confess my sins: it has taken me 20 stinking years to get to a place where I can say, yes, I can let some of this go.

When I do, and someone else preaches... I just had my choir director preach. He recently retired from being a high school choir director, and he's been a choir director in churches for years. He's also the New Albany Symphony chorus director. This guy is amazing, and he loves Jesus. From the beginning I saw the Spirit alive and well in him. This summer I finally said, "Hey, Mike, have you ever thought about preaching for me?" I hold regular communicators retreats where I teach people how to preach, and he said, "You know, Rachel, I think I'd like to try that." He preached on October 18th. You can look it up on the New Albany UMC site. He did an amazing job, and now I hear from my congregation, "My gosh, that was amazing. How did you know he was going to be so great?" Because I saw the Spirit alive and well in him four years ago, and I just kept cultivating. "Maybe someday, Mike, you could preach for me."

Now he's on the teaching team. I think I'm up to thirteen to fifteen people on the teaching team, in a church of 300: laity, clergy, retired pastors, young people, teenagers. I've had four teenagers preach in the four years I've been there. And people who are more seasoned, LGBTQ+ and straight, everything in between, the full kingdom. Everybody. Okay, Natalie, I'm getting really excited. But this is what we get to do as clergy. We get to empower the people around us. We get to pour gasoline on their Godfire, and we get to get out of the way, because someday we're not going to be pastors anyhow. So why don't we get used to it right now? Okay, I'm preaching. Go ahead, Matt.

Part 2: Getting out of the way, participation, and training

Matt: It's biblical, too. Jesus ascended and said, "It's up to you." That's scary. What do you mean you're leaving it up to us? "What you bind on earth will be bound in heaven, and what you loose on earth will be loosed in heaven." That's terrifying.

We've had some interesting discussions about online communion and online baptism. We've been streaming worship since the beginning. We talk to heaven, for God's sake. As I like to say at communion, for those who are online: as we gather around this table, we gather in the presence of all the saints in heaven and on earth, and if the Holy Spirit can unite heaven and earth, the Holy Spirit can bring you into this place.

That is the template for leadership. Jesus ascended. When Jesus was on earth, he sent out the seventy, or the seventy-two, into the communities where he intended to go. Jesus is not sending us places where he will not also follow, and most often, I would say, Jesus is already there. But Jesus ascended and said, "It's up to you." I love the angels, or the visitors, because everyone is looking up at the sky with their mouths open, and they ask, "Why are you staring at the sky? You have a job to do." Go and disciple the nations. Not "make disciples," as if they're products. If I were bishop of the entire planet, I would change that in our mission statement. When are you done making a disciple, as if it's a product in a factory? Go and disciple the nations: teach the nations, and be an example to the nations.

And Rachel is right: we're not going to be here forever. It makes no sense for us to hold the pulpit until we reach mandatory retirement. That's such a squandering of the role of elder, at least in our case. Part of the paradigm of the Hub for Innovation and Dream, Dare, Disrupt is getting out of the way and lifting up another generation while we have the time, energy, and prowess to do it. Jesus ascending is the model, after which we hopefully inspire and equip the people.

Why getting out of the way feels uneasy

Joe Iovino: That getting-out-of-the-way piece can be a little uneasy, can't it?

Matt: Terrifying.

Joe: I just got back from vacation. I have a team of five people, and they handled a major project in my absence. I had almost nothing to do with it during the week while it was happening. In the back of my mind there was that thought: I'm not needed anymore. It's a bit uncomfortable.

Rachel: Joe, you're confessing something that's so true for pastors. Natalie, you asked whether it's challenging. People come to me and say, "Pastor, I'd like to see you at this thing or that thing." I'll never forget the context I came into. I came from Ginghamsburg, where we had multiple campuses and close to 25 people on our teaching team. At our Fort McKinley [spelling to verify] campus we had an experimental Saturday night service after COVID where laypeople preached. Not everybody preached at our largest campus, because not everybody has the same preaching gift, and I recognize that. But it's my job to help people be the best version of themselves.

Then I came to the church I'm at now. The senior pastor before me, Frank, and I can tell you Frank and I are best friends now, so it's okay, had retired. He was used to preaching 48 to 50 times a year. Within my first six months, our associate pastor at the time, Jean Schaefer [spelling to verify], preached, and I sat on the front row taking pictures and hyping her up on social media. Someone went to the lay leader and asked, "What's wrong with Pastor Rachel? Is she sick?" And he said, "No, she shares the Word. Here at this church, we're going to start preaching as a team." So I had a layperson buy into the vision six weeks in.

I have seven retired clergy in my congregation, and I have a rule: if you're retired clergy, you do not set the bench. I just have coffee with them and ask, "What do you want to do?" Some are crystal clear: "Don't ever ask me to preach again. I'm done. Hallelujah." Others say, "My gosh, you would share the pulpit with me? Absolutely." Some have other things God is calling them to do in other pulpits around the country. So in order to fulfill the calling God has on my life, I have to let go of the privilege and power I have in order to empower others, and then we all live out of our calling and giftedness.

Management versus leadership

Matt: To tie a bow on Joe's question: it is terrifying, for at least two reasons. First, many of us have been trained to think it will probably be faster, better, and more efficient if we do it ourselves, because we're trained and we have master's degrees. But that is such a commodity-driven understanding of church. It's like the excellence of the bell choir, instead of the beauty of people volunteering their time. I'm not saying we don't strive for something beautiful or work hard, but there's an ego-driven trap in thinking it's just better, faster, and more efficient if I do it. The first thing Paul said was that love is patient, and I'm still working on that: the patience to bring people along and train them.

Second, clergy are measured on how well they manage the church rather than how well they lead it. Those are two different things. It's terrifying to some because when we let go, things are not going to work perfectly, and we fall forward, as Richard Rohr calls us to do. When I'm being judged on how efficient a manager I am, it's terrifying to let someone fail boldly for the good of the kingdom. The secret to leadership is learning how to disappoint your people at a pace they can stomach. That's part of the secret, and it doesn't look good on a metric at the end of the year.

So, Joe, it's terrifying for more than one reason. One is the patience it takes to make room for others who haven't had your same experience. The other is that we answer to DSs and bishops on our management skills and not necessarily our leadership skills, and that can be terrifying in a commodity-driven, itinerant system. We think, "My God, they're going to send me to a smaller church because I'm not the kind of manager I need to be." We need to move beyond that as a denomination.

Natalie: I was thinking about the challenge while you were talking, and it is challenging. We started a covenant group at one of my churches. It's laity-led, and for the most part I led it to get them ready. There was a part of me that didn't want to go away because I enjoy it, but I knew that if it was going to keep going long after I leave, whenever that may be, and that's between God and the bishop...

Rachel: You laugh because it's true.

Natalie: ...I wanted it to thrive and stay long after. So I stepped away. They had some bumps, but they've owned it and led it, and it blows my mind. There's challenge to it, but there's freedom. The freedom of lifting your people up to take the lead is empowering to them, and also to the pastor, because you have that feeling of, "They've got this, because God has given them the gifts and talents to do it. Who am I to stand in the way of what God is trying to do?"

Rachel: Amen, Natalie.

From observer to participant

Joe: It's also a shift in the mindset of the member, the person coming to worship. They're no longer an observer or a consumer. You're encouraging participation at a level that maybe not everybody can stomach. How do you do that? How does that happen?

Rachel: One thing is that I'm constantly looking for opportunities to share people's Jesus stories. Take this whole idea of preaching as a team. I don't just look at someone and say, "You're it, you're going to preach." Some people hint, "Hint, hint, I want to preach," and I say, "Hint, hint, you're not ready." What I mean is that I look for opportunities first. Maybe you're a liturgist. In our contemporary service we have a host. And I have something people have affectionately named the hot seat. I'm always interviewing people in the congregation in my sermons. I set up two stools, and because I no longer have the video team I once had at Ginghamsburg, you're constantly adapting and figuring out how to accomplish the same thing differently. Sometimes I videotape these, or Zoom them, depending on the people and where they're located, but a lot of times they're live and in person, and I give them three questions.

I do that for a couple of reasons. People expect the preacher to follow Jesus, but everybody else is up for grabs. So when someone in the congregation learns about another person's faith, it is so inspiring. And what I'm looking for is whether I can sense the Spirit alive and well in that person. When they talk, do people listen? Do people lean in?

Part of my challenge right now, Joe and Natalie, is that I have so many people I think should preach. This year at SPRC, the one thing they said to me was that everybody wants to hear me preach more. I preach 34 to 36 times a year. But they added, "We know you're not going to do it, because we know exactly why you do what you do."

Joe: What a compliment. That's awesome.

Rachel: They said, "We know we're not going to get what we want, but we know why you're doing it: you're thinking about the future of this church." One of the metrics we have at this church, what we call our economic engine, what grows the church, is the number of new leaders that we name, empower, train, and deploy.

Training leaders on purpose

Joe: I want to get to that "train" part, because you've been really clear that this doesn't just happen. It's intentional.

Rachel: So, Joe, it's about whether you have a process. I don't have a process for everything, and I'm trying to get there, because I'm a process gal. But take preaching and worship. We have a worship design team that meets at noon on Tuesdays. Some of my people have full-time jobs, so why noon? Because that's when everybody has a lunch hour. We go over the sermon. If you're preaching, we're going to go over your sermon and make you better. We get people into that experience ahead of time.

Once every 12 to 18 months I hold a communicators retreat. I empower those retired clergy to talk about their own experiences of preaching, and I give everybody our process and expectations, with handouts. We spend a Sunday afternoon talking about the gift of communication, whether you're a liturgist, a host, or you end up in the preaching role. I see preaching not just as something the clergyperson does, but as the priesthood of all believers. The gospel comes alive when it's proclaimed in a multitude of voices. It's amazing to watch that happen. Staff members tell me all the time, "I never imagined we could get so much done, because we have processes to get it done."

Right now both Matt and I, as part of the Hub for Innovation, are working with Reverend Dan Jackson. Dan was in the Florida Annual Conference, and he wrote a book about generative, or adaptive, leadership, so he knows a thing or two about this. He's working with both of us on our discipleship and ultimately our leadership pathways. It's one thing for me to call out leaders, but we want to create leaders who multiply themselves: leaders who make disciples who make disciples who make disciples. So how do we do that? We have to open their eyes and help them see. We have to help them move from "I think that person can do that" to sharing the work. In the church we are so good at empowering the biggest doers, and then we wonder why they can't go from doers to leaders. We need leaders. Go ahead, Matt.

The Jethro principle

Matt: I'm shocked you didn't talk about the Jethro principle in any of that. Exodus 18: Moses is burdened with doing all of the work for all of the people, and Jethro says, "You're going to kill yourself. Stop doing that." It's an ancient idea of putting others in leadership to navigate and move among the people.

Part 3: Share thou authority, prototyping, and lead and lag indicators

Matt (continued): Part of our calling is to decommodify what we do as clergy. You left Ginghamsburg for New Albany, and I'm in a two-point charge in New Orleans. It's not about making sure we have a ton of people under our umbrella. It's about making room for new leaders and cultivating them, because it's not just about the next generation. It's about tilling the soil for generations to come. Anyway, Jethro principle: I'm surprised you didn't go there, but you gave me an opportunity to lift up Exodus 18, so I appreciate that.

Joe: The way I hear you talking about it, I'm inspired by your enthusiasm. It's fun to see how excited you are about the work. I also get the sense that the role of pastor is expanded in your idea, beyond the teacher, beyond the leader of the Bible study or the resident scholar. You're discipling people, growing them in their faith, and some of that means letting them lead and do the things God has given them gifts to do. Matt, it looked like you wanted to jump in.

Share thou authority: audition versus rehearsal

Matt: I'll jump in first this time, and then Rachel, you can clean it up. When I'm Bishop of the World, I'm going to do a couple of things. Number one, I'm going to standardize all batteries, so there's only one kind of battery. No more AA or AAA or C, just one battery. The second thing is that it has always bothered me that when we are ordained as elders, the language is "take thou authority" instead of "share thou authority." If I could change that liturgy, I would, because I think it's more appropriate. Pastors are not the sage on the stage, the ones espousing wisdom. We could use the language of rabbi and teacher, but we are also the community partner who carves out space for others to recognize that they are called into the body of Christ as well, regardless of ordination, regardless of education, regardless of where they find themselves. We've been given this opportunity to share authority as community partners and to carve out spaces. There's almost nothing more powerful. Rachel has a thousand stories about people finally recognizing their own worth, whether it's economic, or where they work, or in their own families.

There's a difference between an audition and a rehearsal. When you audition for a show, you bring your best stuff and wait to see if you got the part. That is not rehearsal. Rehearsal is doing the habits of the show in order to perform something good and to work together as a team. There are so many people who are still auditioning for God's love, and that has been firmed up already. Join the rehearsal, babe. You're already in the show. Stop living as if you need to earn it. Live into the habits of the church, like prayer, fasting, worship, and study, the habits of the rehearsal, so that we can work together to tell a good story.

You're all so captivated by that metaphor that no one can say anything.

Natalie: It was good!

Rachel: It's great, Matt. And Natalie, you're going to notice that Matt speaks in metaphors, in beautiful language, and I'm over here saying, "So what?"

Matt: Yes, you're the practical one.

Rachel: At the end of the day I'm asking, how are we moving people from here to there? How is the kingdom coming on earth as it is in heaven? I don't care how great the metaphors are. I want to know whether people can be transformed. You can see that in how we approach things.

No experts in a post-pandemic church

And I want to say that in Dream, Dare, Disrupt, we're not talking to you as experts. We say that from the beginning. There is no expertise in this post-pandemic world, where everything feels unstable. This is experimentation time. This is time to lean into the Spirit and collaborate with other people. And that's not easy. I'm on spiritual retreat right now, and I've been here since Monday. I told Matt this is the least restful retreat I've ever had. I think it's because I'm gleaning beyond the edges of my field. I've got too many things going on, and the world is changing at such a rapid rate, and the expectation of the pastor is, "Change or die, change or die, change or die." Sometimes we just need to take a deep breath and say, "I'm not a human doing, I'm a human being." AI might not have limits. I do.

So we are trying to hold the tension between the traditions, practices, and rhythms of the church and the empowering of people. All of this is centered around real-life people. And the methods, which Matt would call liturgies, are changing in the church because of the technology of our world.

Prototype ministry instead of establishing programs

Matt: It's absolutely true that I speak in metaphor and Rachel speaks in world-changing things people can actually do. I'm over here saying, "Consider dropping a pebble in a pond and seeing the ripples, and understand that's what the Gospel of Mark is about." But what I was going to say is that we need to move beyond the idea that longevity in ministry is a measure of success. We should be prototyping ministry instead of establishing programs. Just because something lasted five years instead of ten does not mean it's a failure. Jesus' ministry lasted a maximum of three years, and scandalously shorter according to Matthew, Mark, and Luke. We don't have time to unpack that, but think of ministry as a prototype. Stop measuring whether something was fruitful in the language of success or failure. Ask what we learned in this prototype.

A couple of years ago I had a conversation with [name to verify; transcript reads "Kathy McShane"], who lamented the way we record church. She said, "I really wish that instead of counting the children in the children's moment, we would count how many of them are laughing. And instead of counting how many adults are in the sanctuary, how many of them linger after worship." That's where discipleship is happening. So we need to get out of this idea of numbers. I had this conversation with Matt Miofsky, who is all about the numbers. He said, "What are you talking about, you hippie? You have to count the numbers." But he was a math major and I was a music major, so that's what you're getting today: the difference between a math major and a music major.

So stop putting it in the category of success or failure, especially on the basis of longevity. There's such pressure to create a program that's going to last fifteen years, instead of saying, "We're going to try something for six months and give it our all, and then look at the fruit."

Rachel: Or six weeks.

Matt: Even six weeks. That's exactly right, because what we do then gives birth to another thing. There's a church we worked with through the Hub for Innovation that had a community garden. We encouraged them to ask, what's the next iteration? What they discerned, and I love this, I wish I could take credit, it was them, I'm just telling their story, was that to improve the discipleship of their garden, it wasn't about sod or seeds or more laborers. They added chairs and benches, because they realized people were working in the garden and leaving. That's not the point. They added places of lingering so that relationships could form. The story is at the garden, not the garden itself. And here's the metaphor again, I'm so sorry: it's not about the produce being produced, but about the conversations that happen while the laborers are in the field. That's where discipleship happens. Go ahead.

Lead and lag indicators

Rachel: I think we have to hold those two pieces in tension. It's really hard to measure laughter, and I do think we have to hold that in tension. But sometimes we help people understand that there are lag indicators and lead indicators. Lag indicators are things like offering and attendance. I still think you have to measure those things. I want to know how much money is coming in, because I want to know whether I can pay my bills. That's the reality. But they give you a picture of what has already happened. Lead indicators are the signs of growth in our church. I've already shared one: new leaders. The number of new leaders we are engaging is an indication of the growth of our congregation. For us, another is children in children's ministry. In most churches, you can have a really thriving youth group and your church not grow. But you can't have a thriving children's ministry and your church not grow.

Matt: It's the difference between barometric pressure and the rain gauge. The rain gauge tells you how much it rained, and that's valuable, because you can prepare: we need sandbags, we need to do drainage. But the barometric pressure tells you what's about to happen. It's setting the conditions in which something is going to happen. Too often we measure the rain gauge instead of leaning into the barometric pressure of the environment we are cultivating. Lead versus lag indicators are crucial, and we are so negligent in recognizing the lead indicators, which are unique to your place of worship.

Rachel: Unique to each congregation and context.

Part 4: Descriptive, not prescriptive; technology; takeaways

Every context is unique

Rachel: I think that's the other thing we have to be really honest about. Again, I have to confess my own sins. I was part of a church, Ginghamsburg, that held Change the World conferences. People came and we said, "Do what we do. Replicate exactly what we're doing, use the formula in your context, and a disciple you will make." What I've come to realize is that every context is unique. That's why, in the Hub for Innovation, we're not obsessed with innovations. We're obsessed with creating innovators. We want to empower people, through the Holy Spirit, to recognize the movement of God in themselves and among their own people. That's going to look different in New Orleans, and different in New Albany, Ohio, and different wherever you are. So when I'm coaching people, I say, "What I'm about to say is not prescriptive, it's descriptive. Don't just take what I say and replicate it. This is one example of something that happened. Think about your own context and take the nugget I'm giving you and apply it for yourselves."

Technology as a tool for discipleship

Joe: I really appreciated that in the book. I've been in ministry long enough to see the plug-and-play mindset: it worked over here, sometimes halfway across the country, so we think we can just plug it into our congregation. You've talked a little about technology in the life of the church. Do you get pushback about that? Are people still fearful of it?

Matt: Joe, I think Sue Phillips is a great source on this. She wrote a piece with the Texas Methodist Foundation on the pastor, or clergy, as technologist. She defines technology simply as a tool that creates a particular result. It doesn't have to have a power button or involve coding. It's a beautiful piece where she talks about how communion is an ancient technology of the church, designed to elicit a response. All the things that go into it, the broken bread, the sharing, the movement of the people, the stained glass, are technologies of the church to accomplish discipleship. If something isn't accomplishing discipleship, I would say throw it away, even if it's cool or interesting.

I'm an early adopter of every technology, just to see whether it's viable. I have an Apple Vision, and no one uses them anymore. I also have the Meta glasses. I want to see whether it's fruitful and whether it can be used in the church. But if we recognize that technology is simply an instrument to elicit a response, we broaden our understanding of what it is.

And of course any change is hard. Even if the change is good, there is still grief and lament. So the pushback may not be about technology itself but about change. Everything is pastoral in that sense: why are people pushing back? Because there's loss and lament over the way we used to do things. A small example from my own context: we changed from registration cards to iPads for check-in, and you would think I had taken down the flag and turned it into a toga, given the irreverence of bringing iPads into the sanctuary. But when I explain why, it makes sense. When you register on the iPad, I immediately get a record of who is there and when they came on campus. I can email everyone who was in worship that day. With cards, it's not that I can't get there, but it takes a couple of days to put the list together and enter it into a database. With the iPad, on your way home from worship, I can send you a message of thanks through Subsplash, especially to our new folks. As Simon Sinek says, preach your why, not the what. When you talk about the why, you get buy-in for mission, not methodology. Let's build consensus around the mission, because the methodology is going to change over time. Which goes back to what Rachel said: it's not about innovation, it's about innovators.

Innovation is about innovators

Rachel: When you hear the word innovation, you think Silicon Valley startup, something technology-based. What we're discovering as we meet with clergy, laity, and students is something different. We have an incredible group of students, and we're doing experimental field education at MTSO. This is our second year. The first year was magic, and the second year is becoming magic. The students have all kinds of different passion areas. I'm working with Beata Ferris, an incredible layperson from the Dakotas Annual Conference. Her full-time job is managing Amplify Media, and she's using it as a tool to disciple, I think, 161 churches across the Dakotas Annual Conference, if that's the right number. I can't believe I remembered that. It's amazing to hear her talk about leveraging technology. Why are they leveraging it? They have been for the last 20 years. They had a video-conferencing tool before there was Zoom, because their churches are so geographically far from one another. It goes back to the question: does this technology connect real people to real people? And does it actually help people grow in their faith and in their connections with God and one another?

Let me take this full circle. It's easy for her to focus on what she has to do, but we've been working on the fact that she has to develop a team. Even with 161 churches, she can't do it by herself. In West Ohio we have more than 900 churches. You just know you can't do it alone. So how do you develop that team, even when it comes to technology? You see how the principles are the same whether we're talking about a community garden or a digital technology.

Joe: Excellent.

Natalie: That's good stuff.

Joe: We're winding down. We're running out of time, and I think all of us could do this for a much, much longer time. You've made this easy on us. This is awesome.

Natalie: A lot of good conversation. Thank you both so much.

Closing takeaways: make the call and permission to play

Joe: If there's one takeaway about leadership, an elevator pitch kind of thing, that you want people to hear, what would it be? Rachel, you want to go first? You look ready.

Rachel: I was just pointing to Matt, because I've sucked up all the oxygen in the room.

Matt: We have core values at the Hub for Innovation, and one of them is "make the call." Do the thing that you're called to do. So the first takeaway is: take courage and make the call. Do what you feel called to do, and understand the difference between leadership and management. Make the call to be the leader, and share thou authority with those you are charged to love.

Rachel: Since Matt said that, I'm going to cheat and use our other core value, which is "permission to play." You have permission to play. We have this understanding in the church that we've got to have it perfect. When you look at what Jesus does in the Gospels, he sent out those 72 people with almost no experience. That makes me want to throw up in my mouth a little bit, even as someone who experiments. Holy cow, what were you doing, Jesus? And yet Jesus was this entrepreneur who said, "No, these people have permission to play. They don't have to sit on the sidelines." So turn inward and say, "I have that permission too." And if it doesn't, quote unquote, work, my gosh, I've just stepped out in faith in a way I didn't before. I've taken a risk.

Joe: Thank you both so much. This has been a fruitful conversation and an inspiration. Your enthusiasm for the work you do is contagious. Thank you for sharing.

Natalie: Yes, thank you so much.

Rachel: Thank you, Joe. Thank you, Natalie.

Matt: Absolutely.

Closing

Natalie: Boy, wasn't that a wonderful conversation, Joe?

Joe: Yes, those two are a lot of fun. I really enjoyed chatting with them.

Natalie: Next time, we're going to have Reverend Magrey deVega from Hyde Park United Methodist Church in Florida. We'll be talking about hope in difficult times. With the Advent season upon us, what a great conversation to have. For some people this season is so difficult, but I'm looking forward to the conversation, and I know Joe is as well.

Joe: Absolutely. Thank you for listening, and we'll be with you again next time.

United Methodist Communications is an agency of The United Methodist Church

©2026 United Methodist Communications. All Rights Reserved