Skip Navigation
The Rev. Alex da Silva Souto of the United Methodist Queer Clergy Caucus leads a prayer prior to an oral hearing before the denomination's top court, meeting in Newark, N.J., questioning whether a gay pastor can serve as a bishop in The United Methodist Church. Photo by Mike DuBose, UMNS.

Photo by Mike DuBose, UMNS

The Rev. Alex da Silva Souto of the United Methodist Queer Clergy Caucus leads a prayer prior to an oral hearing before the denomination's top court, meeting in Newark, N.J., questioning whether a gay pastor can serve as a bishop in The United Methodist Church.

The Rev. K Karpen (right) of St. Paul and St. Andrew United Methodist Church in New York leads a song prior to an oral hearing before the denomination's top court, meeting in Newark, N.J., questioning whether a gay pastor can serve as a bishop in The United Methodist Church. Photo by Mike DuBose, UMNS.

Photo by Mike DuBose, UMNS

The Rev. K Karpen (right) of St. Paul and St. Andrew United Methodist Church in New York leads a song prior to an oral hearing before the denomination's top court, meeting in Newark, N.J., questioning whether a gay pastor can serve as a bishop in The United Methodist Church.

The Revs. Keith Boyette (right) and Walter Fenton confer prior to oral arguments before the United Methodist Judicial Council meeting in Newark, N.J. Boyette represented Dixie Brewster, who questioned whether a gay pastor can serve as a bishop in The United Methodist Church. Fenton is director of development for Good News, an unofficial United Methodist renewal group. Photo by Mike DuBose, UMNS.

Photo by Mike DuBose, UMNS

The Revs. Keith Boyette (right) and Walter Fenton confer prior to oral arguments before the United Methodist Judicial Council meeting in Newark, N.J. Boyette represented Dixie Brewster, who questioned whether a gay pastor can serve as a bishop in The United Methodist Church. Fenton is director of development for Good News, an unofficial United Methodist renewal group.

Previous Next

Spectators pray, sing at Judicial Council

By Kathy L. Gilbert
April 25, 2017 | NEWARK, N.J. (UMNS)

People started lining up at 6 a.m. and three hours later, more than 200 people filled two rooms in the Hilton Newark Penn Station hotel to hear arguments about whether the election of a gay bishop follows or defies The United Methodist Church’s law.

Mountain Sky Area Bishop Karen Oliveto, the denomination’s only openly gay bishop, was not named in the legal documents and did not speak during the three-hour Judicial Council hearing on April 25. But any ruling could affect Oliveto, who was elected and consecrated bishop by the Western Jurisdiction in July 2016. .

Judicial Council hearing

Was last July’s election of a gay bishop by United Methodists in the denomination’s U.S. Western Jurisdiction a violation of church law or a legal elevation of a clergy member in good standing? Representatives of both positions argued their case before the United Methodist Judicial Council, the denomination’s top court, during an April 25 oral hearing. 

Despite the divisiveness in the church over the role of LGBTQ people in the denomination, the hearing was respectful and peaceful.

Many in attendance were members of the United Methodist Queer Clergy Caucus. Dressed in white robes, they silently filed into the meeting room before the hearing convened to pray over all those present.

When the hearing ended, they filled the room again to pray, sing and hold Holy Communion.

For pastors like the Rev. Alex da Silva Souto, this hearing is about the church seeing LGBTQ people as “individuals who want to serve God.”

Souto, pastor of New Milford United Methodist Church in Connecticut, is spokesperson for the caucus.

“As painful as telling our stories is, at least there is a chance our lives will be known and we won’t be perceived as evil, immoral beings. We will be seen as God sees us,” he said.

The Revs. Keith Boyette (right) and Walter Fenton confer prior to oral arguments before the United Methodist Judicial Council meeting in Newark, N.J. Boyette represented Dixie Brewster, who questioned whether a gay pastor can serve as a bishop in The United Methodist Church. Fenton is director of development for Good News, an unofficial United Methodist renewal group. Photo by Mike DuBose, UMNS.

The Revs. Keith Boyette (right) and Walter Fenton confer prior to oral arguments before the United Methodist Judicial Council meeting in Newark, N.J. Boyette represented petitioner Dixie Brewster and Fenton is director of development for Good News, an unofficial United Methodist renewal group. Photo by Mike DuBose, UMNS.

Dixie Brewster, the petitioner whose motion at the South Central Jurisdictional Conference initiated the proceedings, said the hearing was an excellent example of the church “at work to hear both sides of the most controversial issue we face as a denomination.

“My prayer for our denomination is to remain one church. I do not want a divided denomination, and I do not want to ‘choose’ which church I want to be a part of,” said Brewster, a lay representative to the 2016 South Central Jurisdictional Conference

The Rev. Keith Boyette, who represented Brewster before Judicial Council, said the oral hearing was “very respectful of the council, those presenting argument and of others.”

Oliveto and Brewster met for the first time today. They both said they are praying for each other and the church.

Oliveto was accompanied to the hearing by her wife, Robin Ridenour; her mother, Nelle Oliveto, and her childhood pastor from Babylon United Methodist Church, the Rev. Ken White.

“This was the day when we stood on the right side of the law; those are Karen’s words,” said White, who was one of Oliveto’s first mentors. “She has stood on the right side of the law many times. It was not easy to be here, but this was the only place I wanted to be.” White flew in from Lithuania to be at the hearing.

The Rev. K Karpen (right) of St. Paul and St. Andrew United Methodist Church in New York leads a song prior to an oral hearing before the denomination's top court, meeting in Newark, N.J., questioning whether a gay pastor can serve as a bishop in The United Methodist Church. Photo by Mike DuBose, UMNS.

The Rev. K Karpen (right) of St. Paul and St. Andrew United Methodist Church in New York leads a song prior to an oral hearing before the denomination's top court, meeting in Newark, N.J., questioning whether a gay pastor can serve as a bishop. Photo by Mike DuBose, UMNS.

In a press conference after the hearing, Greater Northwest Episcopal Area Bishop Elaine Stanovsky talked about how important it is for each region of The United Methodist Church to choose its own leaders.

“The request before the Judicial Council this morning never named Bishop Oliveto. The arguments were about principle, law and precedence … nothing about Karen — her love, faith, call, sacrifice, mercy.”

During the press conference, Oliveto said, “I love being bishop.”

Oliveto talked about the church’s more than 40-year history of struggle with LGBTQ issues.

“I think that is the hardest thing about our church — for the past 42 years we have talked about LGBTQI people as issues instead of letting the reality of what God has worked in our lives inform the conversation. I pray we can widen the table.”

Gilbert is a multimedia report for United Methodist News Service. Contact her at 615-742-5470 or newsdesk@umcom.org. To read more United Methodist news, subscribe to the free Daily or Weekly Digests.